Cafe Bewilderment Menu

Welcome to Cafe Bewilderment, a hidden gem on 1235 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, where the vibrant ambiance meets a thoughtfully curated menu. Renowned for its cozy atmosphere, this cafe serves as a communal hub where locals gather to enjoy delicious concoctions and delightful baked goods.

The menu features an enticing brunch selection, including the rotating “Pancakes of the Moment” and savory Turkish Eggs, embodying modern culinary creativity. Don't miss the Hot Honey Burrata Toast, where local ingredients shine through stunning flavor profiles.

For lunchtime cravings, indulge in the Bewild BLT or savor the Peach Jam & Prosciutto Sandwich; both showcase a perfect blend of sweet and savory on artisan sourdough. Each bite resonates with freshness and quality.

With welcoming service and an inviting atmosphere, Cafe Bewilderment promises an experience that's not just a meal—it's a moment to relish.

BRUNCH-Y

• PANCAKES OF THE MOMENT

  rotating stack of 2 pancakes

  US$15.00

• TURKISH EGGS

  za'atar greek yogurt | chili oil | mint |olives | poached eggs | served with toast

  US$14.00

• HOT HONEY BURRATA TOAST

  anastasia's artisan sourdough | heirloom tomato | arugula | burrata | red clay hot honey

  US$16.00

• AVOCADO & PICKLED TOAST

  anastasia's artisan sourdough | heirloom tomato | arugula | house-pickled onion & radish

  US$15.00

• HONEY WHIPPED RICOTTA TOAST

  anastasia's artisan sourdough | honey | ricotta | seasonal fruit compote

  US$13.00

• CHIA SEED PUDDING

  chia seed | coconut milk | greek yogurt | maple | berries | toasted coconut

  US$9.00

LUNCH-Y

• BEWILD BLT

  anastasia's artisan sourdough | heirloom tomato | arugula | brown sugar bacon | house-basil aioli | cheddar

  US$15.00

• PEACH JAM & PROSCIUTTO SANDWICH

  anastasia's artisan sourdough | arugula | asiago | balsamic glaze

  US$18.00

• CAPRESE SANDWICH

  anastasia's artisan sourdough | house-basil aioli | heirloom tomato | mozzarella | spinach | basil

  US$14.00

• SUMMER SALAD

  maple roasted sweet potato | arugula | spinach | goat cheese | pine nuts | house-croutons | lemon-mint dressing

  US$14.00

• ROASTED EGGPLANT HUMMUS

  eggplant | garlic | chickpeas | tahini | cilantro evoo | served with pita and rainbow carrots

  US$14.00

MORE?

• gluten-free bread

  sub any toast or bread for gluten-free

  US$3.00

• poached egg

  US$3.00

• avocado

  US$3.00

• brown sugar bacon

  US$3.00

• prosciutto

  US$6.00

• cheddar, mozz or goat cheese

  US$3.00

• burrata

  US$5.00

• bread & butter

  US$4.50

• house-pickled onion & radish

  US$2.00

• peach jam

  US$1.50

• pita

  US$2.00

• carrots

  US$2.00

SWEETS

• AFFOGATO

  Stumptown espresso | vanilla bean gelato

  US$6.00

• PASTRIES & BAKED GOODS

  Various house-made & locally baked pastries | check pastry case of current offerings